Skip to content
Hotels of Earth

Square Toe's Last Resort

519 West Michigan Street, New Buffalo, US

9.8 guest rating· 14 reviews

About this hotel

Charming Patio and Garden

Experience comfort and relaxation in our air-conditioned holiday home with a lovely patio and garden, providing a serene setting for your vacation in New Buffalo.

Modern Amenities

Enjoy modern conveniences such as free WiFi, cable TV, a washing machine, and a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher and oven. Stay cozy with provided towels and bed linen and unwind by the fireplace for a perfect evening.

Convenient Location

Located just 1.5 km from New Buffalo Beach and 48 km from South Bend Regional Airport, Square Toe's Last Resort offers both tranquility and easy access to nearby attractions.

Book now for a delightful stay at our non-smoking property!

These prices drop 5% for members

Membership is free and takes one email address. No password, and the prices on this page update straight away.

Price drops on hotels you save, plus our price research. One click to stop.Already a member? Sign in

Rooms & rates

Apartment

Sleeps 6 · 84 m² · Double bed, Bunk bed

  • Air conditioning
  • Private bathroom
  • Kitchen
  • Coffee/tea maker
  • TV

Amenities

  • Offsite parking discounted rates available
  • Parking
  • Air conditioning
  • Pets allowed
  • Non-smoking throughout
  • Free wired internet
  • Internet access
  • Japanese garden

Location

© OpenStreetMap contributors

519 West Michigan Street, New Buffalo, US

Check-in
from 03:00 PM to 12:00 AM
Check-out
until 11:00 AM

What guests say9.814 reviews

+ Lovely environment+ Thoughtful amenities+ Great beach accessUncomfortable master bed
Cleanliness9.8
Service10.0
Location9.8
Room Quality8.8
Amenities10.0
Value for Money9.8

Absolute perfection!

10.0

We love the close proximity to New Buffalo. We love that it’s pet friendly. The garage conversion to a game room provided hours of entertainment.

Nothing. We had issues with the bed last time, and it was fixed on this stay!

Anthrop · US · 2026-03-30

Guest review

10.0

Highly recommend this place. Very well keep and clean. Peaceful and safe.

Spicy Bear Healer · US · 2026-03-13

Very nice reasonable and I loved my stay

10.0

It’s comfortable and warm

That I gotta leave but one more day wood be nice

Craig · US · 2026-02-25

Guest review

10.0

Wonderful location. Walking distance to restaurants

Brandis · US · 2025-12-24

Absolute gem. Great value.

10.0

Absolutely lovely, well maintained and provides all you can imagine. Loved the enclosed back yard for the dog and the fire pit. Also they supply wood for you. They have thought of everything too for day spent at the beach. Very thoughtful. Loved the place. Also, within walking distance of restaurants and shops. Will definitely come back!!!

Ingrid · US · 2025-09-13

Very good stay, good location and overall good value

10.0

Location

Bed set up. We knew it but description is not entirely tell you

Randal · US · 2025-08-27

Good to know

This property does not accommodate bachelor(ette) or similar parties.

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.

Managed by a private host

A deposit may be required at the property.

Internet

WiFi is available in all areas and is free of charge.

Pets

Pets are allowed. No extra charges.

Children and extra bed policy

Children of any age are allowed.

Children up to and including 17 years old stay for free when using an existing bed.

You haven't added any extra beds.

Any type of extra bed or child's cot/crib is upon request and needs to be confirmed by management.

Parking

Free public parking is possible on site (reservation is not possible).